| Dave Hopeck | 2023 | 1992 | Baseball, 4,
- 1992 – Baseball – Star Ledger – 1st Team All-State Group 1
- 1992 – Baseball – Courier News – Baseball Player of the Year
- 1992 – Baseball – Courier News – 1st Team All-Area Pitcher
- 1992 – Baseball – Home News Tribune – 1st Team All-Area Pitcher
- 1991 – Baseball – Courier News – 1st Team All-Area Pitcher
- 1991 – Baseball – Home News Tribune – 1st Team All-Area Pitcher
- 1990 – Baseball – Star Ledger – 2nd Team All-State Group 1
- 1990 – Baseball – Courier News – Baseball Player of the Year
- 1990 – Baseball – Courier News – 1st Team All-Area Pitcher
- 1990 – Baseball – Home News Tribune – 2nd Team All-Area Pitcher
- 1990, 1991, 1992 – Baseball – Central Jersey Group 1 State Champion
- 1990 – Baseball – Group 1 State Champion
Football, 4,
- 1991 – Football – Home News Tribune – Honorable Mention
- 1991 – Football – Courier News – Honorable Mention
Basketball, 4, 1992 – Basketball – Home News Tribune – Honorable Mention
|
| Jeff Maree | 2023 | 1983 | Football, 4,
- Football – 1981 and 1982 CJG1 State Champion
- Football – Star Ledger – 3rd Team – All-County
- 1982 – Football – Courier News – 1st Team All-Area – Defense
- 1982 – Football – 1st Team All-Mt. Valley Conference
- 1982 – Football – THNT – 2nd Team – All County
- 1981 – Football – All-Conference – Honorable Mention
Baseball, 2 |
| Mark Brower | 2023 | 1982 | Football, 4,
- 1981 – Football – Star Ledger – 3rd Team – All State Group 1
- 1981 – Football – All-Conference
- 1981 – Football – THNT – 1st Team All-County
- 1981 – Football – 2nd Team All-Area
- 1981 – Football – CJG1 State Champion
- 1980 – Football – Mt. Division – Honorable Mention
Baseball, 4, 1982 – Baseball – CJG1 Champion
|
| John Koljesky | 2023 | 1974 | Football, 4,
- Offensive and Defensive Lineman
- 1973 – Football – Star Ledger – 2nd Team – All-State Group 2
- 1973 – Football – 1st Team – All Mt. Valley Conference
- 1973 – Football – 2nd Team – All County
- 1973 – Football – Prep All-American Award
- 1973 – Football – Courier News – All-Area – Honorable Mention
- 1972 – Football – CJG2 State Champion
Track and Field, 3 |
| 1965 Varsity Baseball Team | 2023 | 1969 | Baseball, n/a,
- Record – 14-3
- 1965 – Baseball – Central Jersey Group 2 State Champion – Defeated Highland Park 3-1
- 1st Sectional Championship in School History
- Dan Mauro – Courier News – 1st Team – All-Area; 1st Team All-Mt. Valley Conference
- Ron Virgilio – Courier News -1st Team – All-Area; 1st Team All-Mt. Valley Conference
- FIRST ROW, LEFT TO RIGHT: C. Perone, D. Mauro, D. Seip, R. Hamilton, L. Fiorentino, G. Haney, L. Deddy
- SECOND ROW: J. Billard, J. Hrabovecky, J. Young, R. Virgilio, R. Derwitz, T. Epps, Coach F. Vicendese
|
| 1969 Varsity Football Team | 2024 | 1969 | Football, n/a,
- Record – 8-0-1
- 2nd Place – Central Jersey Group 2
- Mountain Valley Conference Championship
- First Mountain Valley Conference Championship, first undefeated season, and first victory on Thanksgiving Day in school history
- Senior Linebacker Bob Goodwin – 2nd Team All-State, 1st Team All-State Group 2, 1st Team All Area
- All-Mt. Valley Conference – John Woolley, Wayne Frederickson, Bob Goodwin, Ted Petty, Lou Perone, and Mike Shern,
- All-Middlesex County – Bob Goodwin, Mike Shern, and Lou Perone
|
| Charles “Charlie” Weis | 2024 | 1974 | Football, 2
Baseball, 3 |
| Michael O’Donnell | 2024 | 2000 | Baseball, 4,
- 2000 – Baseball – Star Ledger – 1st Team – All-State – Group 1
- 2000 – Baseball – THNT – 2nd Team – All-Area
- 2000 – Baseball – Courier News – 2nd Team – All-Area
- 1999 – Baseball – Courier News – Honorable Mention – All-Area
- 1999 – Baseball – THNT – Honorable Mention – All-Area
- 1998 – Baseball – CJG1 State Champion
- 1998 – Baseball – Courier News – Honorable Mention – All-Area
- 1998 – Baseball – THNT – Honorable Mention – All-Area
- 2007-2014 – Middlesex High School Varsity Baseball Coach
- Overall record 144-62 (.700 win pct)
- 2007 and 2013 – Baseball – NJ Group 1 State Champions
- 2007 and 2013 – Baseball – CJG1 State Champions
- 2012 – Baseball – GMC County Champions
- 2014 – Baseball – GMC Coach of the Year
- 2013 – Baseball – MSG Varsity Coach of the Year
- 2012 – Baseball – THNT Coach of the Year
- 2007 – Baseball – Courier News Coach of the Year
- Played collegiate baseball at Kean University
Yes |
| Stephen Kisly | 2024 | 1982 | Football, 4,
- 1981 – Football – CJG1 State Champion
- 1981 – Football – Star Ledger – 1st Team – All-State – Group 1
- 1981 – Football – THNT – 1st Team – All-County
- 1981 – Football – THNT – 1st Team – All-Area
- 1981 – Football – Courier News – 1st Team – All-Area
Track and Field, 1
Basketball, 4 |
| Oscar Renda | 2024 | 1967 | Track and Field, 2
Wrestling, 4,
- Wrestling – 23-13 Career Record
- 1967 – Wrestling – 3rd Place – Middlesex County
- 1966 – Wrestling – 4th Place – Middlesex County
Football, 4,
- 1966 – Football – Courier News – 2nd Team – All-Mt. Valley
- 1966 – Football – Courier News – Honorable Mention – All-Area
|
| Ronald Virgilio | 2024 | 1965 | Baseball, 2,
- 1965 – Baseball CJG2 Champion
- 1965 – Pitcher – 10-2 record, 1.25 ERA
- 1965 – Baseball – Star Ledger – 2nd Team – All-State – Group 2
- 1965 – Baseball – Star Ledger – 1st Team – All-Middlesex County
- 1965 – Baseball – Courier News – 1st Team – All-Area – Pitcher
Basketball, 1
Football, 1 |
| Al Nicholas | 2024 | n/a | Football,
- 1964-1972 – Head Football Coach – 47-23-2 record
- 1969 – Football – Mt. Valley Conference Champion
- Football – Winning record in 7 of 8 seasons
- Coached Wayne Frederickson, John Woolley, Lou Perone, Mike Shern, Dave Kichula, and Bobby Goodwin
Yes
Baseball,
- 1966 – 1972 – Head Baseball Coach – 62-42 record (never had a losing season)
- 1968 – Baseball – Mountain Valley Conference Champion
Yes |
| Jay Laub | 2022 | 1993 | Basketball, 4
Football, 4,
- 1992 – Football – Home News Tribune – Honorable Mention
- 1992 – Football – All-MVC – Honorable Mention
Baseball, 4,
- 1990 – Baseball – Group 1 State Champion
- 1990, 1991, 1992 – Baseball – Central Jersey Group 1 Champion
- 1993 – Baseball – Star Ledger – 1st Team All-State Group 1
- 1993 – Baseball – Courier News – Baseball Player of the Year
- 1993 – Baseball – Courier News – 1st Team All-Area
- 1993 – Baseball – Home News Tribune – 1st Team All-Area
- 1992 – Baseball – Courier News – 1st Team All-Area
- 1992 – Baseball – Courier News – 1st Team All-Central Jersey
- 1991 – Baseball – Courier News – Honorable Mention All-Area
|
| Brielle Doremus | 2022 | 2009 | Track and Field,
- 2009 – Courier News – 1st Team All-Area – Long Jump
- 2009 – Home News Tribune – 1st Team All-GMC – At-Large
- 2009 – Group 1 Triple Jump State Champion
- 2009 – 2nd Place – Group 1 – 400 Hurdles
- 2009 – 2nd Place – Group 1 – 100 Hurdles
- 2009 – 6th Place – Group 1 – Long Jump
- 2009 – 9th Place – Meet of Champions – Long Jump
- 2009 – 10th Place – Meet of Champions – Triple Jump
- 2009 – 13th Place – Meet of Champions – 100 Hurdles
- 2009 – 3rd Place- GMC’s – 100 Hurdles
- 2009 – 3rd Place – GMC’s – Triple Jump
- 2009 – 2nd Place – CJG1 – 400 Hurdles
- 2009 – 2nd Place – CJG1 – 100 Hurdles
- 2009 – 2nd Place – CJG1 – Triple Jump
- 2009 – 3rd Place – CJG1 – Long Jump
- 2008 – 2nd Place – Group 1 – 400 Hurdles
- 2008 – Central Jersey Group 1 400 Hurdles Champion
- 2008 – 2nd Place – CJG1 – 100 Hurdles
- 2008 – 2nd Place – CJG1 – Long Jump
- 2008 – 3rd Place – CJG1 – Triple Jump
- 2007 – 3rd Place – Group 1 – 400 Hurdles
- 2007 – Central Jersey Group 1 Long Jump Champion
- 2007 – Central Jersey Group 1 100 Hurdles Champion
- 2007 – Central Jersey Group 1 400 Hurdles Champion
- 2007 – 2nd Place – CJG1 – 200m
- 2007 – 3rd Place – GMC’s – 400 Hurdles
- 2007 – 6th Place – GMC’s – Long Jump
- 2006 – 2nd Place – CJG1 – 200m
- 2006 – 4th Place – CJG1 – 100m
- School Record – 110 Hurdles/100 Hurdles – 15.2
- School Record – Long Jump – 17’ 2.5”
- School Record – Triple Jump – 36’ 5.5”
|
| James Fiorentino | 2022 | 1995 | Baseball,
- 1995 – Baseball – Star Ledger – 1st Team All-Group 1
- 1995 – Baseball – Courier News – 2nd Team All-Area
- 1995 – Baseball – Home News Tribune – 2nd Team All-Area
- 1994 – Baseball – Home News Tribune – Honorable Mention
- 1994 – Baseball – CJG1 State Champion
|
| James Sloane | 2022 | 1984 | Baseball, 3
Wrestling, 2
Football, 4,
- 1983 – Football – Star Ledger – 1st Team All-State Group 1
- 1983 – Football – Courier News – 1st Team All-Area
- 1983 – Football – Home News Tribune – 2nd Team All-Area
- 1983 – Football – All-Mountain Valley – 1st Team
- 1983 – Football – 109 tackles, 7 sacks, 1 Punt Block, 1 Interception
- 1982 – Football – Courier News – 3rd Team All-Area
- 1981 and 1982 – Football – CJG1 State Champion
|
| 1994 Boys Basketball Team | 2022 | 1994 | Basketball, n/a,
- Record – 18-3
- 1994 – Basketball – Central Jersey Group 1 State Champion – Defeated Piscataway Tech 55-35 in CJG1 Finals
- Finished #4 in the Courier News Top 10
- Finished #4 in the Home News Tribune Top 10
- BJ Reilly – Star Ledger – 1st Team All-State Group 1
- Kevin Feath – Star Ledger – 3rd Team All-State Group 1
|
| Mike Dessino | 2022 | 2009 | Wrestling, 4,
- HS Wrestling Record – 147-22
- Wrestling – All Time Wins Leader in MHS History
- 2009 – Wrestling – NJSIAA Tournament – 160 lbs. – 4th Place
- 2009 – Wrestling – Region 3 – 160 lbs. – 2nd Place
- 2009 – Wrestling – District 12 – 160 lbs. – 1st Place
- 2009 – Wrestling – GMC Tournament – 160 lbs. – 1st Place
- 2009 – Wrestling – Home News Tribune – 1st Team All-Area
- 2009 – Wrestling – Home News Tribune – 1st Team All-Area
- 2008 – Wrestling – Region 3 – 152 lbs. – 1st Place
- 2008 – Wrestling – District 12 – 152 lbs – 1st Place
- 2008 – Wrestling – GMC Tournament – 152 lb. – 2nd Place
- 2008 – Wrestling – Courier News – 1st Team All-Area
- 2008 – Wrestling – Home News Tribune – 3rd Team All-Area
- 2007 – Wrestling – NJSIAA Tournament – 152 lbs. – 8th Place
- 2007 – Wrestling – Region 3 – 152 lbs. – 2nd Place
- 2007 – Wrestling – District 12 – 152 lb. – 1st Place
- 2007 – Wrestling – GMC Tournament – 152 lb. – 1st Place
- 2007 – Wrestling – Home News Tribune – 1st Team All-Area
- 2007 – Wrestling – Home News Tribune – 1st Team All-Conference
- 2007 – Wrestling – Home News Tribune – 2nd Team All-Area
- 2006 – Wrestling – GMC Tournament – 145 lbs. – 2nd Place
- 2006 – Wrestling – Home News Tribune – Honorable Mention All-Area
Track and Field, 1
Football, 3 |
| BJ Reilly | 2022 | 1994 | Baseball, 1
Track and Field, 1
Cross Country, 2,
- 1993 – Cross Country – Home News Tribune – Honorable Mention
- 1992 – Cross Country – All-Valley Division – 1st Team
Basketball, 4,
- 1993 – Basketball – Central Jersey Group 1 Finalist
- 1994 – Basketball – Star Ledger – 1st Team All-State Group 1
- 1994 – Basketball – Courier News – All-Central Jersey 1st Team
- 1994 – Basketball – Home News Tribune – 2nd Team All-Area
- 1994 – Basketball NJICA North/South All-Star
- 1994 – Basketball – Averaged 15 points, 6 assists, 7 steals per game
- 1993 – Basketball – Courier News – 1st Team All-Central Jersey
- 1993 – Basketball – Home News Tribune – 2nd Team All-Area
|
| 2004 Varsity Softball Team | 2019 | 2004 | Softball, n/a,
- Overall Record: 24-2
- Seniors – Dana Ferraro, Lindsey Hopper, Vanessa Torres
- NJSIAA Central Jersey Group 1 Finals: MHS – 1 Roselle Park – 0 (10 innings)
- NJSIAA Group 1 Semi-Finals: MHS – 5 New Egypt – 1
- NJSIAA Group 1 Finals: MHS – 10 Cedar Grove – 0
- Only Group Championship in MHS Softball History
- 2004: #1 Home News Tribune – Final Top 10
- 2004: #1 Courier News – Final Top 10
- 2004: Erica Lordi – Courier News Player of the Year; 2nd Team All-State – All Groups
- 2004: Courier News Awards – 1st Team All-Area – Erica Lordi, Dana Ferraro; 2nd Team All-Area – Ana Abourashed; 3rd Team All Area – Meghan Reilly
- 2004: The Home News Tribune Awards – 1st Team All-Area – Erica Lordi, Dana Ferraro; 2nd Team All-Area – Meghan Reilly; 3rd Team All Area – Ana Abourashed
|
| Bruce Phillips | 2019 | 1983 | Football,
- 1981: Football – Central Jersey Group 1 State Champion
- 1982: Football – Central Jersey Group 1 State Champion
- 1981: Football – 1st Team – All-Conference
- 1981: Football – 1st Team – All-Area
- 1982: Football – 1st Team – All-Area
- 1982: Football – 1st Team – All Mountain Valley
- 1982: Football – 1st Team – All-County
- 1982: Football – 2nd Team – All-State – Group 1
Track and Field |
| Carl Mayer | 2019 | 1976 | Football,
- 1974: Football – Central Jersey Group 1 State Champion
- 1974: Football – All-County
- 1974: Football – All Mountain Valley 1975: Football – All-Area
- 1975: Football – All-County
- 1975: Football – All Mountain Valley
- 1975: Football – 1st Team – All-State – Group 2
- 1975: Football – Daily News All-Metro Jersey
- 1975: Football – The Home News Tribune Player of the Year
- 1975: Football – Top 100 Players in NJ
Track and Field,
- 1975: 440 Yard Champion – Mountain Valley
- 1975: 440 Yard Champion – CJG2
- 1975: 440 Yard 2nd Place – Group 2
- 1975: 440 Yard 7th Place – Meet of Champions
- 1975: AAU NJ State Pentathlon – Junior Olympics
- 1975: 2nd Place – AAU NJ State Decathlon
- 1975: 5th Place – National Decathlon (National Record in 1,500m Decathlon – 4:16)
- 1975: 1st Place – AAU NJ State 400m
|
| Ken Kelly | 2019 | 1975 | Football,
- 1972: Football – Central Jersey Group 1 State Champion
- 1974: Football – Central Jersey Group 1 State Champion
- 1974: Football – All-County
- 1974: Football – All Mountain Valley – Offense
- 1974: Football – All-Area
- 1974: Football – 1st Team – All-State – Group 2
- 1974: Football – 3rd Team – All-State – All-Groups
Basketball
Baseball |
| 1981 Varsity Football Team | 2018 | 1981 | Football, n/a,
- Overall Record: 8– 1
- Tri-Captains – Mark Brower, Mike Ballah, Joe Degati
- 1981: Central Jersey Group 1 State Champions
- Central Jersey Group 1 Championship: MHS – 14 South River – 7
- Central Jersey Group 1 Semi-Finals: MHS – 2 Point Beach – 0
- 1981: All-State Group 1 – 1st Team – Paul Halada & Steve Kisly
- 1981: All-State Group 1 – 3rd Team – Mark Brower & Joe Degati
- 1981: Post-Season Awards – Seniors – M. Esposito, M. Ballah, M. Girvan, W. DeMato, J. Degati, S. Kisly, B. Bunting, P. Halada, M. Brower
- 1981: Post-Season Awards – Underclassmen – E. Bontempo, J. Maree, B. Phillips, D. Zakashefski
|
| Brian Parenti | 2018 | 1992 | Baseball,
- 1990, 1991, 1992 – Central Jersey Group 1 Champion
- 1990: Mt. Valley – All-Valley Division Team
- 1991: Mt. Valley – All-Valley Division Team
- 1991: 2nd Team – All-Area – Home News Tribune
- 1991: 1st Team – All-Area – Courier News
- 1992: Mt. Valley – All-Valley Division Team
- 1992: 1st Team – All-Area – Courier News
- 1992: All-Middlesex County – Star Ledger
- 1992: 1st Team All-State – Group 1 – Star Ledger
- 1992: Batted .431
- 1992: 25-1 Team Record
- 1992: Central Jersey Group 1 Champion
- 1992: #2 Home News Tribune – Final Top 10
- 1992: #4 Courier News – Final Top 10
Football, 1991: Mt. Valley – All-Valley Division – Running Back
|
| Stan Spiridon | 2018 | | Softball,
- 1999 – 2005: Head Coach
- 2000, 2001, 2002, 2003, 2004, 2005: GMC Blue Division Champions (6x)
- 2000, 2001, 2002, 2003, 2004: Central Jersey Group 1 Champions (5x)
- 2004: Group 1 State Champion
- 2005: Greater Middlesex Conference Softball Champion
- 2000: Softball Coach of the Year – Courier News
- 2005: Softball Coach of the Year – Home News Tribune
- 2005: #1 Home News Tribune – Final Top 10
- 2005: #1 Courier News – Final Top 10
- Career Record: 142-33
Yes
Basketball, Boys Basketball
1977 – 1983: Varsity Head Coach
Girls Basketball
1989 – 1995: Varsity Head Coach
Yes |
| Mike Shern | 2018 | 1970 | Football,
- Varsity Captain: 1969 Football Team
- 1969: Mountain Valley Champions – 8-0-1
- 1969: Football – 1st Team – All-Mountain Valley – Courier News
- 1969: Football – All-Middlesex County
Basketball
Baseball, 1970: Baseball – 1st Team – All-Area – Courier News
“Mike was a tremendous team leader, unofficial captain of the club. He gave 150% regardless of the situation or inning.” – Coach Al Nicolas (6/12/70)
|
| Dan Smith | 2018 | 1987 | Wrestling,
- 1985 & 1986: CJG1 Sectional Championship Team
- 1985-1986: District 18 Champion – 123 lbs.
- 1986-1987: District 18 Champion – 123 lbs.
- 1986-1987: Region 5 Champion – 123 lbs.
- 1986-1987: NJ State Wrestling Tournament – 4th Place Finish – 123 lbs.
- 1986: Junior Nationals – 2nd Place
Cross Country
Baseball
Wrestling,
- Coach – 26 Years (North Brunswick, Middlesex, & Watchung Hills)
- 2015: New Jersey Scholastic Coaches Association Hall of Fame Inductee
Yes |
| 1990 Varsity Baseball Team | 2017 | 1990 | Baseball, n/a,
- Overall Record: 19 – 7
- 1990: New Jersey Group 1 State Champions
- Group 1 State Championship: MHS – 1 New Providence – 0
- Group 1 State Semi-Finals: MHS – 11 Woodbury – 4
- Central Jersey Group 1 Championship: MHS – 8 South Hunterdon – 0
- 1990: All-State Group 1 – 2nd Team – Dave Hopeck, Roger Nepton & Brian Parenti
- 1990: All-County – 1st Team – Brian Parenti
|
| Meghan Reilly O’Donnell | 2017 | 2005 | Softball, 4,
- 2003: All-Blue Division
- 2004: All-Blue Division
- 2004: All-GMC – 2nd Team
- 2004: All-Group 1 – 2nd Team
- 2005: All-Blue Division
- 2005: All-Area – 1st Team
- 2005: All-GMC – 1st Team
- 2005: All-Group 1 – 1st Team
- 2002-2005: CJG1 State Champion
- 2004: Group 1 State Champion
- 2005: GMC Softball Champion
Basketball, 3
Cheerleading, 3 |
| Brian Feath | 2017 | 1992 | Basketball, 4,
- 1,322 Career Points – Basketball
- 1st 1,000 Point Scorer in MHS History
- All-Time Scoring Leader for Boys Basketball
- 1992: Central Jersey Group 1 – 1st team
- 1992: All-County – 1st Team
- 1992: All-Area – 1st Team – Courier News
- 1992: All-Conference – 1st Team
- 1992: All-Group 1 – 1st Team
- Played in the 1992 CJG1 Sectional Finals vs. Keyport
Yes
Baseball, 2
Cross Country, 2 |
| Paul Halada | 2017 | 1982 | Football, 3,
- 1981: CJG1 State Champion – Football
- 1981: All-Area
- 1981: All-County
- 1981: All-State
Track and Field, 4 |
| Dan Zakashefski | 2017 | 1983 | Football, 3,
- 1981 & 1982: CJG1 State Champion – Football
- 1981: All-Conference
- 1981: All-Area – Honorable Mention
- 1982: All-Area
- 1982: All-Mountain Valley
- 1982: All-County – Star Ledger
- 1982: All-County – Home News Tribune
- 1982: All-State
|
| 1974 Varsity Football Team | 2016 | 1974 | Football, n/a,
- Central Jersey Group 1 State Champions
- Defeated Hillsborough 24-6 in Atlantic City, NJ
- 1st Tournament State Champion in school history
Awards:
- All-County Team: K. Kelly, C. Mayer, B. Parlo
- Mt. Valley Conference – Offense: B. Parlo, K. Kelly, J. Valent
- Mt. Valley Conference – Defense: B. Mansolina, C. Mayer, D. Donnatelli, P. Kubeck, A. Kosloski
- All-Area: B. Parlo & K. Kelly
- All-State: B. Parlo & K. Kelly
|
| Bobby Shern | 2016 | 1964 | Football, 3
Basketball, 3
Baseball, 3, Co-Captain
|
| Rachel Ryan | 2016 | 2000 | Basketball, 4,
- 2000: 1,059 career points (1st female 1,000 point scorer in school history)
- 1997: All-Mountain Valley Conference – 2nd Team
- 1998-2000: All-Mountain Valley Conference – 1st Team
Softball, 4,
- 1998: Associated Press All-State – 2nd Team
- 1998-2000: All-Mountain Valley Conference – 1st Team
|
| Danny Mauro | 2016 | 1966 | Basketball, 4,
- 1965: All-Mountain Valley Conference – 2nd Team
- 1966: All-Mountain Valley Conference – 1st Team
- 1966: All-Area Courier News – 1st Team
- 1966: All-Central Jersey – 1st Team
- 1966: All-State – Honorable Mention
- 1966: Scored 45 points vs. Bernardsville (then school single game record)
- 1965-1966: 510 points (then school single season record)
- Over 900 career points
- 1966: Mountain Valley Conference Champion
Baseball, 4,
- 1965: All-Mountain Valley Conference – 1st Team
- 1965: All-Middlesex County – 1st Team
- 1965: All-State Group 2 – 1st Team
- 1965: All-State – 2nd Team
- 1965: All-Area Courier News – 1st Team
- 1966: All-Mountain Valley Conference – 1st Team
|
| David Johnson | 2016 | 1973 | Football, 3,
- 1972 Central Jersey Group 2 Co-Champion (MHS 1st State Championship)
- 1972: Team MVP – 1,600 total yards (1,100 passing, 500 rushing)
- 1972: All-State Group 2 – 1st Team
- 1972: All-Mountain Valley Conference – 1st Team
- 1972: All-County – 1st Team
- 1972: All-Area – 2nd Team
- Set then school record for TD passes in one season
- Led Middlesex County in TD Passes
Baseball, 3,
- 1973: Mountain Valley Conference Champions – Captain (.403 BA)
- 1973: All-Mountain Valley Conference – 1st Team
- 1973: All-County – 2nd Team
Basketball, 2 |
| Albert Carter | 2016 | 2025 | Football, 3
Basketball, 3
Track and Field, 3, School Records
- 2003: 100M – 10.8 seconds
- 2004: 200M – 21.7 seconds
- 2044: Triple Jump – 43.3 feet
State Championships
- 2004: CJG1 Champion – 200M
- 2004: Group 1 Champion – 200M
- 2005: GMC Champion – Triple Jump
|
| Dana Ferraro | 2015 | 2004 | Soccer, 3,
- 2002: 1st Team All-Blue Division, Co-Captain
- 2001: 1st Team All-Blue Division, Captain
Basketball, 4,
- 1,167 career points
- 2003, 2004: Varsity Basketball – Co-Captain
- 2004 Courier News Player of the Year
- 2004: 1st Team All-GMC, All-State Group 1
- 2001 – 2004: 1st Team All-Blue Division
- 2004 GMC Blue Division Champion
- 2004 Central Jersey Group 1 Champion
- Played collegiate basketball at Stony Brook University
Softball, 4,
- 2001 – 2004: GMC Blue Division Champion
- 2001 – 2004: Central Jersey Group 1 Champions
- 2004: Group 1 State Champion
- 2004: First Team All-State, All-State Group 1, All-Area, All-Blue Division, Co-Captain
|
| Wayne Frederickson | 2015 | 1972 | Football, 3,
- 1969: 1st Team All-Mountain Valley Conference
- 1970: 1st Team All-Group 2, 1st Team All-Mountain Valley Conference, 1st Team All-Middlesex County
- 1971: 1st Team All-State, 1st Team All-Area, 1st Team All-Mountain Valley Conference, 1st Team All-Middlesex County
- Named to the Home News Tribune All-Century Team
- Played collegiate football at Northwestern University
Basketball, 1
Baseball, 2 |
| Bobby Goodwin | 2015 | 1970 | Football, 3,
- 1968: 1st Team All-Mountain Valley Conference
- 1969: Varsity Football – Co-Captain
- 1969: 1st Team All-Mountain Valley Conference, 1st Team All-Middlesex County, 1st Team All-Area, 1st Team All-Group 2, 2nd Team All-State
- Led the Blue Jays to an 8-0-1 record, 1st Mountain Valley Conference Championship, 1st undefeated season in school history, and 1st victory on Thanksgiving Day vs. Manville High School
Track and Field, 2 |
| Paul Murphy | 2015 | n/a | Football, –Head Coach from 1972 – 1989; longest tenured Football Coach in school history
- 5 time State Champion: 1972, 1974, 1981, 1982, 1984
- Overall record: 86-73-5
- Coached 8 All-State football players during his career
- 1972: New Brunswick Home News Coach of the Year
- 1974: Newark Star Ledger Coach of the Year
- 1981: Plainfield Courier News Coach of the Year
- 3 time honor by the Bill Denney Chapter of The National Football Foundation
Yes
Wrestling,
- Head Coach from 1962-1978, and in 1987
- Record: 114-88
- Coached 3 State Place Winners
- Member of the NJ Wrestling Hall of Fame
Yes |
| Don Somma | 2015 | 1964 | Football,
- 1963: Varsity Football Captain
- 1962: All-Mountain Valley, All-Middlesex County, All-Area Honorable Mention
- 1963: 1st Team All-Mountain Valley, 1st Team All-Middlesex County, 1st Team All-Area, 1st Team All-State
- 1964: University of South Carolina Freshman Football Team Captain
- 1967: University of South Carolina Football Captain
- 1967: 1st Team All-South Carolina Colleges
- 1967: Sporting News Defensive Player of the Week vs. Duke
- 1967: 1st Team All-ACC – Defensive Tackle
- 1967: All-American – Honorable Mention
Basketball, 1
Baseball, 4 |
| Jack Wilson | 2015 | 1981 | Football, 1
Wrestling, 3,
- Sophomore Record: 16-5
- Junior Record: 32-0
- Senior Record: 21-1
- 69-6 career record (.920 win percentage, best in school history)
- 1979: 2nd in Districts
- 1980: 1st in Middlesex County, 1st in Districts, 1st in Regions, and State Champion (Heavyweight)
- 1981: 1st in Middlesex County, 1st in Districts, and 1st in Regions
- The ONLY State Wrestling Champion in Middlesex High School history
Track and Field, 3,
- Middlesex High School Record – Shot Put – 55-10 ½
|
| Kurt Wilson | 2015 | 1985 | Football, 3,
- 1984: Varsity Football – Co-Captain
- 1984: First Team All-State Honors by the Associated Press
- 1984: Second Team All-State by the Newark Star Ledger
- 1982 and 1984: Central Jersey Group 1 State Champion
- Played in the North vs. South All-Star Game at Rutgers
- Played collegiate football at the University of South Carolina
- 1990: University of South Carolina Football Team Captain
Wrestling, 1
Baseball, 1 |
