| Softball | n/a |
- Overall Record: 24-2
- Seniors – Dana Ferraro, Lindsey Hopper, Vanessa Torres
- NJSIAA Central Jersey Group 1 Finals: MHS – 1 Roselle Park – 0 (10 innings)
- NJSIAA Group 1 Semi-Finals: MHS – 5 New Egypt – 1
- NJSIAA Group 1 Finals: MHS – 10 Cedar Grove – 0
- Only Group Championship in MHS Softball History
- 2004: #1 Home News Tribune – Final Top 10
- 2004: #1 Courier News – Final Top 10
- 2004: Erica Lordi – Courier News Player of the Year; 2nd Team All-State – All Groups
- 2004: Courier News Awards – 1st Team All-Area – Erica Lordi, Dana Ferraro; 2nd Team All-Area – Ana Abourashed; 3rd Team All Area – Meghan Reilly
- 2004: The Home News Tribune Awards – 1st Team All-Area – Erica Lordi, Dana Ferraro; 2nd Team All-Area – Meghan Reilly; 3rd Team All Area – Ana Abourashed
|
